« Ann Arbor goes GIZMO | Main | To boldly go where no probe has gone before. »

May 24, 2005

Math Question No Touchdown for Football Fans

From the Boston Globe, now here's a case of "math in the real world" not working out quite as expected:

On an end-of-grade test this month, seventh-graders had to calculate the average gain for a team on the game's first six plays. But the team did not gain 10 yards on the first four plays and would have lost possession before a fifth and sixth play.

The team opened with a 6-yard loss, a 3-yard gain and a 2-yard loss, which would have made it fourth down with 15 yards to go for a first down. The team's fourth play was just a 7-yard gain, yet it maintained possession for a 12-yard gain and a 4-yard gain on two additional plays.

So do the creators of math problems have an expectation to be grounded in reality or is the football example above just a variation on the old "imagine a spherical cow" or "the frictionless ice" or "the chicken and a half can lay an egg and a half every day and a half" types of fiction for the sake of example that comes with the territory in math and science problems?

Posted by ExploreLearning at 09:22 AM in Math (Real World) | Permalink

Comments

I don't think I've missed a Dolphin game in years, and even I didn't understand that math question. Doesn't football just involve GOOOOAAALLLLLSSSS, and not yardage gains?

And stop making fun of the spherical cow!

Posted by: Rp | May 24, 2005 1:40:47 PM

hey i love the games

Posted by: Terri | Aug 16, 2007 1:33:16 PM

Post a comment